Wow! How awesome! We have been coming here for years and absolutely love the hot pizzas with awesome crust and delicious sauce! Always piping hot and fantastic! Today we decided to venture off our usual routine and had the homemade lasagna and meatballs! Came with a side salad and fresh homemade breadsticks! Lasagna is a true Italian homemade recipe that is out of this world. After having it, I swear I will never go anywhere else for lasagna. This is a beautiful peaceful place that is family owned that you will be happy to bring your friends and families to over and over! The staff is super polite and the owners are down to earth and passionate about the good things they have to offer.
Overview
If you're in the mood for a slice of authentic Italian pizza, Little Sicily Pizza in Surprise, Arizona, is the place to be. Located at 18795 N Reems Rd, this family-owned pizzeria brings the flavors of Sicily right to your table. Whether youβre a local or just passing through, Little Sicily Pizza is sure to impress with its cozy atmosphere, friendly service, and mouthwatering dishes that capture the essence of Italian cuisine.
The menu at Little Sicily Pizza is full of irresistible options, all prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients. From the first bite, itβs clear that this restaurant doesnβt cut corners when it comes to taste. The pizza is the star of the show, and for good reason. You canβt go wrong with their signature Sicilian pizza, featuring a perfectly crispy crust and topped with a rich tomato sauce, gooey mozzarella, and your choice of premium toppings. The Margherita pizza is a classic, offering a simple yet flavorful combination of fresh basil, mozzarella, and a light drizzle of olive oil.
What sets Little Sicily Pizza apart from other pizzerias is the attention to detail. Their dough is made in-house daily, ensuring each pizza has the perfect texture. The sauce is made from ripe tomatoes and seasoned with just the right blend of herbs, creating a tangy yet sweet base for their pizzas. Whether you prefer a traditional pizza or something more adventurous, like their BBQ chicken or Mediterranean veggie pizza, you'll find something that suits your taste buds.
But itβs not just about pizza. Little Sicily Pizza also offers a variety of appetizers, pastas, and subs. The garlic breadsticks are a perfect starter, warm and buttery, with just the right amount of garlic to keep you coming back for more. The pasta dishes are also a hit, with the lasagna being a crowd favorite. Layers of pasta, savory meat sauce, and melted cheese make this dish a comfort food classic. If you're in the mood for something lighter, their fresh salads are a great option, made with crisp greens and topped with a variety of delicious dressings.
The restaurant itself is welcoming and relaxed, making it the perfect spot for a casual meal with family or friends. The staff at Little Sicily Pizza is friendly and attentive, always ensuring that your dining experience is enjoyable from start to finish. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or sitting down for a longer meal, the service is always prompt, and the food is consistently fresh and flavorful.
For those who prefer dining at home, Little Sicily Pizza offers convenient takeout and delivery options. The quality of the food doesn't change when it's brought to your door, and it's a great way to enjoy a delicious meal without leaving the comfort of your own home. Many locals have praised the consistency of the food and the promptness of the delivery service, making it a reliable choice for pizza cravings at any time.
When it comes to the price, Little Sicily Pizza offers great value for the quality and portion sizes. Whether you're feeding a hungry family or just looking for a satisfying meal, you'll find that the prices are reasonable for the level of quality you're receiving. It's not hard to see why this spot has become a favorite in Surprise, AZ.
With so many great menu items and an inviting atmosphere, Little Sicily Pizza truly stands out as a must-visit dining spot in the area. From the first bite to the last, itβs clear that this pizzeria is committed to delivering an exceptional dining experience. Whether youβre in the mood for a classic pizza, a hearty pasta dish, or a tasty appetizer, youβll leave satisfied. For anyone looking to indulge in a delicious, authentic Italian meal, Little Sicily Pizza is the perfect place to visit.
Good to know
Service options
β Outdoor seating β No-contact delivery β Delivery β Takeaway β Dine-inHighlights
β Fast service β Serves local specialtyPopular for
β Lunch β Dinner β Solo diningAccessibility
β Wheelchair-accessible car park β Wheelchair-accessible entrance β Wheelchair-accessible seating β Wheelchair-accessible toiletOfferings
β Alcohol β Beer β Coffee β Comfort food β Quick bite β Small plates β WineDining options
β Lunch β Dinner β Dessert β Seating β Table serviceAmenities
β ToiletAtmosphere
β Casual β CosyCrowd
β GroupsPlanning
β Accepts reservationsPayments
β Credit cards β Debit cards β NFC mobile payments β Credit cardsChildren
β Good for kids β High chairsParking
β Free of charge street parking β Free parking lot β ParkingPhotos
Location
Reviews
I have been to 80+ pizza spots in az. Easily top 3!! Crust is old school crispy sauce is out of this word, toppings n cheese were very generous. Now that I ate its in the top 5 of my life out of 800 spots.. im 47 monday n heart attack at 40. Lol..
This is the best Chicago deep dish Iβve ever had! This is a Chicago mom and pop place that weβre lucky enough to have here in AZ. Their pasta is really good as well. Prices are great and the service is exceptional!! Thank you guys!!!
I'm glad to have my favorite pizza again. Service and food are great! Hope to be back soon!
The Italian Beef Sandwich is Absolutely AMAZING... Literally the BEST I've ever eaten! Staff is Friendly and Incredibly Helpful! The restaurant is small, yet very cozy =] HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!
What an incredible hidden gem! This unassuming little place has the most incredible Italian food! The sauce tastes like an Italian nonna simmered it all day with the perfect fresh spices. The lasagna has 8(!!) delicate noodle layers, I've never tasted anything like it! My dad had the chicken parm which was juicy & tender & delicious, even the side salad was super fresh. I can't wait to try the pizza! If you can come on a Thurs, Fri, or Sat you might get to meet Elliott, the hardest working young man in Arizona. Even though its a counter-service restaurant that does mostly takeout, he bent over backwards to make sure everyone felt welcome & provide the kind of customer service you'd expect in a fancy restaurant that costs 4x as much. We overheard some customers that seemed like they were going to be difficult but he was a total champ & made them feel really cared for, I was so impressed. I'll be back as often as I can, I live in Tempe but this place is absolutely worth the trip!
The only negative was our crust on our pizza was tough. The pizza sauce was delicious and the toppings were great. We will return but probably won't order the pizza. They have some wonderful looking sandwiches we want to try. This is a true Mom & Pop style restaurant, very small but it does have outside seating. Overall we enjoyed the evening.